Thursday, October 11, 2012

Ryan Can Spare Us His Inner City Condescension

The media and Internets were buzzing the other day about Paul Ryan walking out on a Michigan TV interviewer when the questions about crime went where Ryan didn't want to go.

The interviewer asked about gun problems in the country; Ryan rephrased it as a crime problem - - back to right-wing and pro-NRA talking points - - and then turned it to inner city life, as he saw it.

Here is the YouTube posting from the TV station.

Also: one mainstream media account, and a parsing of the event by PolitiFact.

I don't think Ryan's snippiness at the interviewer should be the takeaway from the exchange, though this Veep business certainly has ballooned his ego.

Rather it's his remark about preventing violent crime in the inner cities - - "to help teach people good discipline, good character..." The full context is below:

"But the best thing to help prevent violent crime in the inner cities is to bring opportunity in the inner cities, is to help people get out of poverty in the inner cities, is to help teach people good discipline, good character. That is civil society. That’s what charities and civic groups and churches do to help one another make sure that they can realize the value in one another."
Does Ryan make the same remark when he is campaigning in white, rural America, or suburbia, where there are incidents of school shootings, violent bullying, drug-and-alcohol violence?

Are there only character and discipline problems in central cities?

I remember a small-town Wisconsin school counselor telling me when I was writing a series for The Milwaukee Journal on rural drug use that when she encountered substance among her female students she knew that there was a good chance that incest would eventually come out as a factor.

Ryan's preachiness undermined a decent message about the value of charities and civic groups because he pandered for a conservative audience far from the inner cities, and added nothing but stereotypes and fear to the campaign.


Sue said...

Ryan is both thin-skinned and clueless. The best way to handle him is to point at him and laugh. Here's a start, please do a post on this, please please?

Anonymous said...

The first thing I thought of when I saw that interview was the Sikh temple Oak Creek, not inner city Milwaukee.

Anonymous said...

I also noticed that remark about "good values". That is a very convenient way to say this is happening somewhere other than my neighborhood and I don't care and I am not going to pass any laws to help these people.