Friday, July 29, 2016

WI voting barriers erected by Walker, GOP ruled illegal

A huge win for unfettered voting, as a federal judge in Wisconsin - - on the same day related measures were invalidated in North Carolina - - 

ruled that several GOP-written, Scott Walker-endorsed-and-signed voting barriers were unconstitutional.

I have no doubt that as with GOP-written, Scott Walker-endorsed-and signed legal barriers to the provision of legal abortion services which were also ruled illegal, Walker and his allies knew these laws were un-American and would be knocked out in the Federal Courts.

But they went ahead knowingly and intentionally contaminating the legislative process and rigging the system with the public's funds for as long as possible and as deeply as possible to gain for themselves and their party as much partisan advantage as possible - - just like the operation of Walker's gubernatorial campaign's secret email system and illegal use of public resources evaded the Open Records law until its revelation in 2010 - - until law-and-order was restored.

Such a joke that Walker has thrown in with the ill-informed demagogue Donald Trump's purported law-and-order campaign when Trump has endorsed the illegal torture of battlefield prisoners and execution of their families and while signature Walker programs which were twisted into law are being ruled illegal.


Waiting for Trump to belittle Mike Pence

After Trump mocks Mike Bloomberg:
Donald J. Trump
"Little" Michael Bloomberg, who never had the guts to run for president, knows nothing about me. His last term as Mayor was a disaster!

Pence has this to say:

Donald Trump's running mate decries 'name calling' in politics

During post-DNC Twitterstorm, Trump negates Trump

Donald J. Trump
"Little" Michael Bloomberg, who never had the guts to run for president, knows nothing about me. His last term as Mayor was a disaster!
Mike Bloomberg is doing a great job as Mayor of New York City. Ray Kelly is a great Police Commissioner. 

Waukesha officers, Pence workers didn't get democracy memo

[Updated] Negative image-building:
At Pence’s first public event since he was introduced as the Republican vice presidential candidate two weeks ago, a [Washington] Post reporter was barred from entering the venue after security staffers summoned local police to pat him down in a search for his cellphone.
This was in a public venue, mind you, and the local police were Waukesha County Sheriff's deputies on the public payroll.

Even after leaving his computer and cellphone behind - - and the general public was allowed to bring their cellphones into the event - -  the reporter was 'escorted' from it.

Waukesha officials see nothing wrong with their behavior.

Neither does Pence, who ducked the issue with a wordy, non-responsive response.

Your freedom party at work.

Thursday, July 28, 2016

Will Trump come to WI? And does Walker help?

I'm sure that the GOP will send Donald Trump into Wisconsin more than once until the November election because Wisconsin will be a battleground state and local boy Reince Priebus can't be accused of withholding the standard bearer from the Party's Chairman's home state.
Trump at lectern before backdrop with elements of logo "TRUMP"
But I don't think bringing The Donald to Wisconsin is necessarily a plus for Trump and his down-ballot hostages, because everywhere he goes he'll harden Democrats' resolve to send him packing and take the rest of the ticket (Ron Johnson, for example) with him.

Ditto to putting Scott Walker on a public stage with Trump. 

Walker is mired below 40% in the polls - - not much of a coattail - - and it doesn't help the GOP that Walker flip-flopped on backing/not backing Trump.

Nor does it speak well for Walker that he ultimately abandoned GOP voters who turned out in the primary in larger numbers for Ted Cruz than for Trump.

Another issue boding badly for Trumping in Wisconsin: explaining how he's an authentic Republican and party presidential nominee in the state where the Republican Party/Party of Lincoln was born.

Like Madison, or Milwaukee or a dozen other Wisconsin cities, I don't think Ripon will be on Trump's itinerary.

On the other hand, I am predicting a heavy schedule in Wisconsin for Hillary Clinton, Tim Kaine, Barack Obama, Joe Biden, Michelle Obama and Bernie Sanders.

I figure we'll see more in Wisconsin of Mike Pence, the Indiana Governor and Trump running mate.

Though the Walker/Pence team in Waukesha got the GOP show off to a rocky start.

I expect to see Trump family members and lesser surrogates.

Coming to a suburb near you: Chris Christie and Dr. Ben Carson.

Just some early thoughts.

We'll see.

Republicans are done with all that Freedom stuff

It's hard to miss the fact right now that the former party of the Great Emancipator has devolved into serving up Freedom Fries in the US Capitol, running an intentionally misnamed "Freedom Caucus" in the House of Representatives that keeps that body inert while the GOP-controlled Senate has frozen the US Supreme Court into 4-4 gridlock now free to do little but spin its wheels.

And the anti-freedom party has hit political bottom by nominating for President a candidate who would rule the country rather that serve it with an un-American, dictatorial "I alone can fix" the-country promise.

Trump at lectern before backdrop with elements of logo "TRUMP"
Except with the help of Russian one-man governing band Vladimir Putin and his military's secret cyberspies whom Trump has asked to cancel out American citizens' rights to privacy and communication.

A candidate who is parroting the discredited "law-and-order" programs and slogans of Richard Nixon - - uniquely forced by American law to resign for having broken several laws - - and is willing to order American soldiers to break the law by torturing prisoners and murdering their families.

A candidate who doesn't have the mental order to understand the nuances and formal difference in our most fundamental legal structures between The Articles of the US Constitution which frame our free society and the amendments to it which further ensure our freedom by constraining the government - - another concept foreign to Trump.

Who, unprepared for public service, let alone the Presidency, embrace dictatorial, one-man, law-and-disorder rule, would:

* Obliterate the First Amendment's sacred guarantee of freedom of religion by banning further Muslim immigration while surveilling Muslim citizens and communities here;

* Negate free speech and assembly at his rallies ("Knock the crap out of [protesters] them");

* Already toss out, literally, a free press, and;

* Pick a vice-presidential running mate who yesterday emulated The Boss by enlisting government agents to frisk and ban reporters assigned to practice at GOP events their First and Fourteenths amendments freedoms of speech, assembly, due process and equal protections for their employers, readers, listeners and viewers.

The more you listen to Trump, or follow the freedom-cancelling agenda of similar power-hogging Republicans like Gov. Scott Walker who routinely travels Wisconsin at public expense and has held dozens of by-invitation events and appearances closed to the general public and reporters, the more you understand that freedom these days for Republicans is freedom to control people and public resources by either one-man rule or one-party, gerrymandered, 'chamber of commerce' management - - or both.

And, of course, the GOP's two main freedom goals:

* The freedom from Barack Obama. 

* The freedom to maintain the all-male Presidency,

You know, to take the country back.

Wednesday, July 27, 2016

Walker, Ryan have endorsed the Trump-Putin ticket

[Update] So Donald Trump has found today's equivalent of Richard Nixon's plumbers, except that Trump's team of invited thugs makes Nixon's collection of minor spies and ideological chumps look beyond amateurish and give unimaginable elevation and definition to 'outside agitators.'
Trump at lectern before backdrop with elements of logo "TRUMP"
The blustery and erratic head case but Head Republican 2016 Donald Trump - - whom Paul Ryan and Scott Walker and other Republican 'leaders' have endorsed for President of the United States and Commander-in-Chief of our nuclear-tipped military - - has publicly called on the ex-KGB officer-for-life and Russian 'strongman' Vladimir Putin -- whose military is conducting cyber warfare against our government and others, and whose army invaded and occupied and annexed (stole) part of Ukraine, and whose air force is harassing US aviators, and whose operatives are suspected of assassinating Putin foes in and out of Russia - - to commit espionage and cyber crime during the presidential election to help Trump by hacking Hillary Clinton's email.

Setting aside Trump's towering political stupidity and pure freebie handed to Democrats while media are concentrated at their convention where President Barack Obama is poised to speak on national television tonight, it must be occurring for the umpteenth time to Walker and Ryan and the other fools who have thrown in with Trump that the man is not well.

Wednesday p.m update: MSNBC's Chuck Todd chastises GOP officials' silence in the face of what he calls "an attack on US sovereignty."

Making the #NeverTrumpers look prescient, while the others stuck with him by choice look as ridiculous as their publicity-absorbed candidate who gathered the media today to give Vladimir Putin his illegal campaign assignment.

Lock who up?

I know one who needs it for his own good and our protection.

Easy explanation for WI road funding, repair crises

His trail continues to run one-way - - out-of-state. 

And when he drops in here, a State Trooper driver smoothes out the bumps, which works out well, since Walker is asleep at the wheel:
Wisconsin faces nearly $1 billion shortfall on roads

Bill O'Reilly, meet Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice Dan Kelly

You may have missed Fox News talker Bill O'Reilly's jaw-dropping minimization of slavery after First Lady Michelle Obama noted in her speech Monday night at the Democratic National Convention that the White House was built with slave labor.

O'Reilly knows the statement is true, but felt compelled to add a peculiarly callous and ignorant bit of spin:
Slaves that worked there were well-fed and had decent lodgings provided by the government, which stopped hiring slave labor in 1802. 
The slaves were "well-fed and had decent lodgings?"

What is he conjuring up - - a summer camp brochure?

There's something, anything virtuous about enslavement?

So you say, what would you expect from a Fox News blowhard - - at least there aren't serious people in policy-making positions who could so completely misinterpret the evil essence of owning people?

Regrettably, there was another such sugar-coated distortion of slavery by Atty. Daniel Kelly, whom Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker just elevated to a seat on the Wisconsin Supreme Court  - - and there's no doubt that Walker saw Kelly's statement because Kelly included it in his official application to Walker for the position:

In his application, Kelly included a 2014 book chapter in which he wrote same-sex marriage would rob marriage of any meaning and likened affirmative action to slavery. 
"Affirmative action and slavery differ, obviously, in significant ways," Kelly wrote. "But it's more a question of degree than principle, for they both spring from the same taproot. Neither can exist without the foundational principle that it is acceptable to force someone into an unwanted economic relationship. Morally, and as a matter of law, they are the same."
Slavery is "an unwanted economic relationship?" 

What kind of mind can reduce and reconfigure the sinful, violent, obscene personal and cultural coercion of thousands and thousands of captured human beings - - many of whom died in chains on slave ships or were raped and murdered while in bondage in America after losing their freedom, names, families, identity - - into a sanitized collection of obfuscatory, overly syllabic words like "unwanted economic relationship?"

What is this: An Econ 101 term paper topic?

I'll tell you what's an unwanted economic relationship. Getting slammed and overbilled by a phone company. Having your email address sold by one political campaign to another, leaving you with pesky electronic solicitations or fliers on your doorstep. 

Spending your life as a captive, in a foreign continent and country where no law protects you, but enforces your kidnapping and shields your owner - - even if you are, by some apologist's warped standard, well-fed and lodged - - is a helluva lot more profound and consequential than being in "an unwanted economic relationship."

And what kind of Governor responds by saying to all that by saying through an official action: 'just the guy to sit on the state's highest court.'

Yeah, we know. The Badger who would be President.

Tuesday, July 26, 2016

Tracking precedents for DNR draft review of Kohler golf course

[Updated from 7/25/2016] I'd recently posted about the slow response from the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources to an Open Records request I'd submitted about a high-profile and controversial development plan.

I did get some information last week and will bring you the details, but first some background.

The agency had released a draft Environmental Impact Statement (EIS)  - - a first state step in studying major projects which could impact land, air, water, and other socio-economic factors - - that reviewed the suitability of constructing an 18-hole, privately owned high-end golf course along Lake Michigan on a wooded, water, sand dune and Native-American artifact-laden 247-acre nature preserve south of Sheboygan that also abuts the popular Kohler-Andrae State Park.

More about the state park's relationship to the golf course plan will be included in another post coming today, but for now, back to the draft EIS:

Since the DNR has yet to receive a detailed, formal proposal with requisite permit applications for the project from the Kohler Company - - the land owner and potential developer - - project opponents are crying foul over what they see as cart-before-the-horse state input that could help the developer eventually nail down project approval.

I had noticed that Mike Thompson, a DNR official, told The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel's Lee Bergquist that other plans had also received similar draft EIS analysis prior to the submission of formal proposals:

Mike Thompson, environmental analysis team supervisor, cautioned that the document is a draft and could be changed, based on comments from the public, and as other information becomes available. 
Thompson said there have been instances when the DNR has moved ahead with the environmental impact report before receiving a formal application. He said the company did not ask for the analysis to be done before it filed an application.
I asked several people familiar with the DNR if they could recall such instances and no one could supply a relevant example, so I posed the same question to the agency, and asked for the records, or links or citations for them.

A fair question, I thought, given that the project would be developed by a powerful and well-connected Walker campaign donor whose golf course plan would also take control of between four-and-twenty acres of public land in the adjoining state park.

In the DNR's response to my request, David Siebert, director of the 
Bureau of Environmental Analysis and Sustainability said via email:

When Mr. [Mike] Thompson was speaking with Mr. Berquist [Sic], before his article of June 29, 2016,  he was referencing projects that he was familiar with, where DNR worked on a joint EIS with the PSC.  In those circumstances that Mr. Thompson was thinking about during the interview, a DNR/PSC EIS was developed before DNR had all the DNR permit applications in hand.  We would be happy to provide you a  copy of  one or more those documents if you like. 
NR 150 and WEPA require that DNR conduct an environmental analysis in advance of making permit decisions. 
Siebert later wrote:
The example Mr. Thompson was talking about was the Fox Energy Generation Project, Final EIS August 2002. I checked this morning and unfortunately the PSC electronic file system does not have a link to the document...There are likely other examples like that in that timeframe, but that was what he was thinking about at the time of the interview.
To be clear, I appreciated the information and Siebert's offer to supply hard copy material about that project.

If I am correct, The Fox Energy Generation Project involved proposed power plant and related supply facilities which ultimately were not constructed - - an undertaking far greater in cost and scale than the possible nature preserve golf course and which could justify preliminary reviews as early as possible.

I assumed when I read The Journal Sentinel story that the DNR had a longer and more recent list of draft EIS reports - - plural - - for projects similar in scope and timeline to the golf course project.

More later, perhaps.

Tuesday update:

Siebert today emailed me this further information and I am happy to add it in full:

Mr. Rowen—

FYI.  This was not one of the examples that Mike Thompson was thinking of during his June 28 interview with Mr. Bergquist, but is responsive to your open records request.

The Department prepared an EIS for this proposed project, although no stocking permit application was ever received. See the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law at the end of the document.

·         Final Environmental Impact Statement for the Proposed Introduction and Stocking of Landlocked Salmon into Big Green Lake. The document is available under Doc ID # EA0214 at:


or at the direct link to the document:

Walker's WI producing brain drain, jobs/business exit

Scott Walker's punitive policies are clear signals to academics, job-seekers, business startups and others that they are not wanted in the state where partisan anti-intellectuals including Walker, known UW-basher and Assembly GOP Speaker Robin Vos and others are turning over policy-direction to the far-right and its conservative corporate funders.

I wrote last year:

I would bet it all that somewhere within the Walker administration, or in the GOP legislative caucus meetings or their Madison and Waukesha watering holes, ''let em' move somewhere else" is a familiar refrain, like "Go Pack, Go..." 
Again, "good riddance" is in the air, and in state policy, too, like a new official motto or state slogan.  It used to be "We like it here." Now it's more along the lines of, "We'd like some of you, a lot of you, to leave."
So Scott Walker and Robin Vos - - say hello, er, goodbye to two innovative, UW-Madison professors who got the message and are leaving for California, and taking with them a cutting-edge game development program and more than $10 million in grants and contracts.

The headline in Isthmus says it all:

Time to leave

[Kurt]  Squire and [Constance] Steinkuehler, married UW-Madison professors who co-direct the UW-Madison Games + Learning + Society Center, are leaving the UW at the end of the year, having accepted positions at the University of California-Irvine. 
While part of their decision was driven by the academic and professional opportunities Irvine offers, another part was driven by something else. 
“The climate of the state of Wisconsin helped contribute to the feeling that it was time to leave,” says Steinkuehler. “State government and state universities don’t always align, but the way the conversations have gone lately — so disrespectful, so cantankerous — statesmanship has gone out the window.” 
Squire agrees: “When there is this kind of open hostility and uncertainty in what the future will hold, it’s hard to innovate in an environment like that.”
There is also news in Walker World of more job cuts by Caterpillar, which, after taking over the venerable Milwaukee-area construction equipment maker Bucyrus-Erie, enforced workforce reductions despite promises of a post-takeover honeymoon.

And the announced sale of Joy Global, the former P&H heavy equipment maker headquartered within sight of Miller Park, again signals a loss of white collar staffers, production-line work and prestige.

That blow mirrors the loss of Oscar Mayer's blue and white collar jobs in Madison from the state which Walker keeps saying is open for business.

Walker never had a genuine plan to attract and retain business, other than billboards at the borders, sending Lt. Gov. Rebecca Kleefisch to cold-call business from Chicago hoping to embarrass a border state at the time run by Democrats, dissing more successful Minnesota with another cross-border speaking tour and setting up his political prop known as the Wisconsin Economic Development Corporation - - which has failed and fallen into so many repeat scandals and chief executive bailouts that Walker himself punted from the WEDC chairmanship he set up for himself because his WEDC's baggage gave the lie to what he was selling successfully to no one on the presidential campaign trail last year.

Meanwhile, workers' wages here have been set back or frozen by Walker's 100% resistance to raising the minimum wage above $7.25 per hour, his signing right-to-work and related prevailing wage restriction bills that impede collective bargain, and, of course, Act 10 - - his destruction of public sector bargain and real growth in take home opayt - - which together with deep cuts to the UW system.

Back to those two talented UW professors who said it was time to leave.

For Walker, Mission Accomplished.

Monday, July 25, 2016

DNR golf course review ripped by adjoining DNR state park's ex-super

[Updated] I'd supplied some fresh information earlier today about the ongoing battle documented on this blog for the last two years over whether a privately-owned, high-end golf course proposed in a Lake Michigan nature preserve - - 

- - by a major Scott Walker campaign donor should win approval by the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources.

The plan proposes turning over to the development between four and twenty acres of the adjoining Kohler-Andrae State Park.

The DNR held a public meeting in Sheboygan last week on its draft Environmental Impact Statement, (EIS), issued for the plan even though the agency has no formal application or permit submissions for the project.

I thought people should read why the former Superintendent of the Kohler Andrae State Park - - 36-year DNR veteran James Buchholz - - said in his formal comments that the draft EIS "is flawed and incomplete...lacks scientific analysis and study, and depends way too heavily on the Kohler Company’s own very slanted studies and papers."

His emailed comments to the DNR were copied to project opponent Friends of the Black River Forest, which is distributing them. 

July 23, 2016

I am strongly opposed to the development of the proposed 18-hole golf course in the Town of Wilson by the Kohler Company. I also feel the DNR’s proposed Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) is flawed and incomplete for the following reasons:

·      The Dept. of Natural Resources has no right and nor any responsibility to “give away” 4-plus acres of publicly-owned state park land to anyone, especially to a “for-profit” business or person for the purpose of increasing the revenue of such business or to increase the income of any person or corporation.  Kohler-Andrae State Park’s land acquisition was supported by Federal LAWCON funding.  As such the conversion of these public lands to a private person or corporation is NOT justified to accommodate their financial interests and is not 
permitted except in very rare circumstances.
·      The EIS document map shows a total of over 19 acres that are being considered for Kohler’s development with no detail as to the actual footprint of the development.  The EIS mentions the size of maintenance building to be constructed on state park lands but does not state the size of the paved parking lot that would need to service the proposed maintenance building.  The area listed for conversion is listed as “lightly used”… as if it doesn’t matter if the land is given away or not.  

This is far from the truth. The area may not be used as heavily as the park’s beach and picnic areas but this was by design by park management.

Hiking trails, boardwalks, restrooms, etc. were left out of this area to keep it in its natural sand dune state to protect this rare ecosystem as 
mandated by the Kohler-Andrae State Park Master Plan.

·      The DNR’s EIS states that permitting the transfer of public land for Kohler’s own private use and the development of roads, shop buildings and parking areas on these fragile and rare sand dune lands would “not set a precedent” My question and that of anyone else reading this EIS is how could it not?
              If this is approved for Kohler, “ I “ would like to request and expect approval for my own 4 acres so I could set up my own business, perhaps a hotdog stand.  Of course, like Kohler, I would have to ban park visitors from ever setting foot on my part of their public land again (unless they purchase one of my 
hotdogs of course).

              This land transfer for private use should not be allowed regardless of the political involvement, DNR appointments and pressure from the Governor’s office. The DNR is supposed to represent the preservation and protections of all public lands.   Park visitors should not have to be denied access to their public lands just to appease a large corporate donor to a particular party or person. 

If so, all confidence is lost for this agency now and into the future.

The EIS hints at what is already known in that the DNR intends to “alter” the existing property master plan in order to give away this part of the park to a corporation.

 The Kohler-Andrae Master Plan was developed over several years of local and statewide public input and was approved by the Wis. Natural Resource Board.  It cannot be altered without permission and approval of the natural resource board “and” without new local and statewide public debate/hearings.

·      The EIS does not include the acreage necessary and loss of sand dune habitat needed to construct the proposed “roundabout” at the park’s office area. The design shown in the document would be way too small to accommodate all the heavy traffic and especially the larger delivery semi and panel trucks that would be entering and exiting the state park and the golf course on a regular basis.

It would not even accommodate most of the larger RV’s and longer camping trailers that would need to maneuver through this small roundabout.  A much larger roundabout would be needed which would require at least an acre of land (sand dune habitat) and create even more lost public land and habitat.

·      The traffic system LOS (Level of Service) calculations were incomplete and as stated in the DNR EIS report, did not occur during the heaviest use times for traffic on weekends.  With more than 400,000 visitors a year the Kohler-Andrae entrance is already burdened by way too many vehicles, RV’s and trailers.  Backups all the way out to the Co. Hwy V have regularly occurred during busy times and even during the evening hours if special event are held in the park.The addition of even more heavy traffic due to Kohler’s golf courseand their proposed clubhouse/restaurant  by cars, delivery trucks and most likely buses from their own hotels,  would certainly cause traffic jams and confusion for all, especially since their highest use period would “also” be on weekends.

Visitors to both the state park and the golf course will be frustrated by this unnecessary traffic congestion. It would also hamper all police, fire and rescue emergency calls.  According to Kohler’s plan for the course it would host some high profile events as well.  If so, “where” would all these people park and how would they all access the golf course at the same time of year that the state park has so much incoming and outgoing traffic?

·      If Kohler receives a positive DNR EIS report it should only be approved without the loss of publicly-owned state park land for their entrance road, roundabout, shop building and parking lots.

 There is no convincing need to use state park lands to accomplish their project other than it is the “cheapest” way to go for the Kohler company.  This should not be a consideration for the DNR to give away state park lands. The alternative D-3 of the EIS is the correct route to go and should be selected by the DNR’s EIS as the only course to take.  

The D-3 version allows Kohler to make use of their own existing entrance off of Co. Hwy V (12th Street) north of the state park with a direct eastern access to their property.

Yes, this would mean the construction of an expensive bridge over the Black River and additional road building on their property but again, this is the Kohler Company’s concern and not the DNR’s. There is no logical reason why the golf course shop building and parking lots could not be built on their own property adjacent to the existing state park shop building as was originally planned. 

There is no reason to take away public state park land and destroy rare sand dune formations and habitat for Kohler’s shop building and parking area development when they have 247 acres of their own property to work with.

·      The EIS does mention a few negative effects of Kohler’s plan to deforest 50 or more acres of mature timber but there are many more.  This unique forest, dune and wetland area is an extension of the rare sand dune ecosystem that is currently protected and managed by the DNR on the Kohler-Andrae State Park property.

Clear cutting, pulling stumps, and bulldozing these areas for the purpose of installing golf course greens will forever destroy a fragile landscape and ecosystem that has evolved in its present state since the last ice age over 14,000 years ago. Unfortunately the Kohler company does not see any problem with destroying this very unique and rare Great Lakes sand dune area for the purpose of building a golf course for their wealthy clients. 

The EIS does mention that there are “several rare species”  that will be destroyed by Kohler’s development. A few are listed but not all.  Some are Federally threatened species such as the dune or pitcher’s thistle plus state threatened species including most of the dune grasses such as marram/beach grass, thick-spiked wheat grass, sand reed and many others.  Many of these are only found growing on Great Lakes sand dunes and nowhere else in the world.
·      Bird, mammal, reptile, amphibian and insect life (some rare/threatened) that have adapted to both the wooded and open dune habitat would also be displaced or destroyed by the Kohler development.  The combination of the state park and Kohler forested area has long been known as an “Important Bird Area” (IBA) for migratory birds along Lake Michigan.

Throughout the entire history of the DNR and the Conservation Commission before that, staff managers, biologists and scientists have supported and strived to protect these areas at all costs.

The EIS should make a strong statement against the destruction and fragmentation of this important IBA and Great Lakes dunes habitat.  It should be noted also that an active bald eagle nesting site is located only a short distance to the north of the Kohler property which most likely will be negatively affected by the massive tree removal, development and increase in public use of this area.

·      The EIS also mentions several “globally rare” wetlands that will be lost in the construction of the golf course. The DNR’s own Bureau of Endangered Species has termed these rare wetlands (Interdunal wetlands) as the rarest, most irreplaceable habitat/ecosystems in the state of Wisconsin. 

If the DNR doesn’t protest the irreversible/permanent destruction of this important and threatened ecosystem who will?

Wetland replacement mitigation was mentioned as a possible replacement of these lost wetlands but it must be very clear to all reading the EIS or least the DNR staff themselves that these rare ridge and swale interdunal wetlands cannot be reproduced artificially elsewhere.

 The EIS should make this clear to all readers in addition to explaining why these wetlands and surrounding dune formations should be protected from development.

·      The effects of groundwater well water drawdown due to the proposed high capacity wells usage is listed in the EIS as “uncertain”.  This uncertain designation is not appropriate and should be studied in more detail by someone other than the Kohler Company. 

Their estimate of using 15-25 million gallons a year (just to water their golf course) plus about 2 million more of potable water usage seems  low.  These estimates were all based on water usage at Kohler’s other golf courses.  This reasoning fails to take into account that none of the other courses were built on 247 acres of nearly pure dry sand with little or no water holding capacity. 

·      There was mention that the high capacity wells located within Kohler-Andrae State Park have not caused any problems to the surrounding landowners but obviously the park doesn’t use 15-25 million gallons of water for irrigation/watering lawns. 

In fact, the park doesn’t water any of its lawns and never has.  

The park only uses well water for flush toilets, water fountains, two small fill towers at the dump station for campers and to provide water at few shower stalls and sinks for campers. 

Kohler’s only advise for local neighbors who will run out of water when their wells run dry is to contact them for help and “they” will determine if they believe their water drawn down are at fault or not.

This information (clearly written directly by Kohler staff) does NOT belong in a DNR EIS document in my opinion and is of no help to local citizens who will be effected by the massive water use for the golf course.  

In addition, the state park itself may have water issues with its own wells due to the high draw of ground water aquifers which will affect all 
state park visitors and campers.

·      Overall, I feel the DNR’s EIS is incomplete, lacks scientific analysis and study, and depends way too heavily on the Kohler Company’s own very slanted studies and papers.

Much of the EIS document seems to be a rehash of Kohler’s EIR report from March of 2015.

At that time citizens were asked to submit questions and concerns about that document as did the DNR itself. To date very few answers or responses have been given by the Kohler company to those concerns and are clearly NOT covered in the proposed EIS.

It would seem impossible to complete a DNR EIS without that data and lots of other very important “missing” information about the golf course and related facility/roads development plans.

 Unfortunately as a result of this missing documentation and lack of detailed construction and road/parking lot placement plans it is really not possible for citizens to comment fully on Kohler’s proposal or the DNR’s current EIS.
James Buchholz
(retired superintendent of Kohler-Andrae State Park)
Sheboygan County Resident

           Plymouth, WI