skip to main |
skip to sidebar
The official assault in right-wing GOP Gov. and corporate bellhop Scott Walker's Wisconsin against the people's Constitutional water rights in an intentionally-trashed Public Trust Doctrine continues apace as our one-party, GOP-controlled state steals birthright public assets and leaves behind a Broken Trust Doctrine instead.
After imperiously assisting in the earliest days of his first term a wetlands' fill for a campaign donor/developer, followed by signing a business-enabled wetlands development bill in front of a cheering convention of Realtors and developers, Walker has put the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources on staffing and budgetary life support with just enough energy left to set more wetlands-fillings and Big Ag groundwater withdrawal permissions into motion.
So it's not surprising that within a week we would learn that the DNR is preliminary approving the largest wetlands-fill in a decade that will grind down pristine acreage for the frac sand underneath, and is goosing along a plan to fill more wetlands so another donor/developer can build a high end golf course along Lake Michigan and partially into an adjoining state park.
These projects' planers pledge to fix up some other degraded land as environmental compensation, but everyone knows that so-called 'artificial wetlands' are not as good as the real thing, and you wouldn't have to scramble to out together a remediation plan off-site if you weren't bulldozing it in the first place.
And this 'fill-it/pave-it' mentality I've written about for years - - notable exception, Walker's potholed roads as all that money heads for overbuilt major highway expansion - - spins off into local communities, like Wauwatosa, where leaders have worked with developers and even the County and UW-M to continually grab off and level what's remaining of the people's land known as the Milwaukee County grounds.
Those policy-makers probably figure, if the state can do it, why can't they?
The bigger picture with facts and figures, here:
Here are a few points of context for the preliminary state approval of a Wisconsin frac sand mine that will destroy a Jackson County pristine wooded wetland, and also require huge amounts of groundwater for its operation: ...
the Walkerites have used law and policy and political power in Wisconsin - - this GOP/corporate control has been an under-covered, carefully crafted take-over operation - - to tilt benefits and access in a heavenly way towards big business and the executives who own them.
1. This is just the latest example of Wisconsin right-wing GOP Gov. and corporate tool Scott Walker and his party helping the private sector absorb public resources in a loop of mutual self-interest across multiple business interests:
2. There are records of $10,300 in campaign donations from the land owner and people associated with it to Walker's campaign, according to this report by the Wisconsin Democracy Campaign.
3. Projects like this will probably accelerate in Wisconsin and elsewhere because Walker is lobbying Donald Trump to give states more control over environmental policy-and-decision making, and because Trump has named former pro-business Oklahoma Attorney General Scott Pruitt as administrator of the US Environmental Protection Agency.
Finally - - remember the admonition about Wisconsin waters and The Public Trust Doctrine laid down by the State Supreme Court more than a half-century ago that I have put on the front page of my blog and should guide conservation and public policy here forever:
"A little fill here and there may seem to be nothing to become excited about. But one fill, though comparatively inconsequential, may lead to another, and another, and before long a great body may be eaten away until it may no longer exist. Our navigable waters are a precious natural heritage, once gone, they disappear forever," wrote the Wisconsin Supreme Court in its 1960 opinion resolving Hixon v. PSC and buttressing The Public Trust Doctrine, Article IX of the Wisconsin State Constitution..
Well, the Koch brothers and friends got their greenhouse gasman
just where they wanted. The rest of us can drop dead.
The head of the Environmental Protection Agency administrator said Thursday he does not believe that carbon dioxide is a primary contributor to global warming -- a stance at odds with leading climate scientists.
Some true climate change facts and links to website to the contrary, here.
Readers of this blog know that I have followed for some years the proposed construction of a high-end, privately-owned golf course in a forested/wetland/artifact rich nature preserve along Lake Michigan
adjacent to Kohler-Andrae State Park - - which would have to give up several acres of public land so the project can be completed as preferred by the developer, a major Scott Walker donor.
I've also noted in the context of corporate influences over Walker's "chamber of commerce mentality"-driven Department of Natural Resources that the golf course plan is being reviewed by staff from the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources until a formal permit application was finally submitted this week, thus having aided for months at public expense the project's chances for approval without making the developer put it all in writing for opponents to vet:
The agency is being so helpful to the golf course proponent that it hasn't yet required the submission of a formal permit application that would greatly inform the public and expand the record - - so right there is some DNR provided, one-sided, taxpayer-paid advantage and assistance - - but the DNR did discuss whether to discipline a DNR staffer for giving opponents some public information relevant to the matter.
Does all this sound even-handed and equitable to you?
As I also noted last year.
Along those lines, I'd heard the other day that the DNR invited 24 staffers to a February 21st in-house meeting to discuss the project's wetlands issues, so when I read that project designers are now saying that the project could achieve greater wetlands preservation...
- Wetland preservation: Only a small amount of wetland – 3.69 acres – would be impacted by the golf course, and there will be no impact to rare interdunal wetland. In addition, Kohler Co. is offering a wetland mitigation plan to restore and enhance additional ridge and swale wetland in the same watershed as the project.
...I asked myself again:
Does this sound even-handed and equitable to you?
Would you and your project - - or should you be among a proposal's opponents with a moving target to aim at - - get this much attention from DNR?
YUGE publicity from Samantha Bee for our ham-and-cheese sandwich addicted Governor:
Full Frontal Insta-vestigation: Scott Walker Is A Human Garbage Disposal | TBS
We have the 4th worst-repaired state roads, and we're 33rd of 50 in job creation, but, by God, Wisconsin's got a top-tier TV magnet as Governor.
And happy to have had Walker's penchant for food Tweets on the menu back in 2014, here, with too many political critiques to count:
For the record:
You could have read or written this fresh story and headline about Wisconsin's sluggish, stalled, low-wage and dismal economy - - and Walker's broken first-term, 250,000 new jobs-promise - - often since Walker was sworn in.
Wisconsin drops to 33rd in job growth
Here's a 2015 story:
Wisconsin ranks 32nd in job growth over five years
Here's a 2014 story:
Wisconsin job growth 33rd in nation
Yet there he is, running around Wisconsin talking third term at by-invitation-only 'listening sessions' and touring America giving speeches, dining with Trump, serving as chair of the Republican Governors Association as if he had a compelling success story to tell and sell about Wisconsin on his watch.
[Updated from 3/6 and 3/7/17] Here are a few points of context for the preliminary state approval of a Wisconsin frac sand mine that will destroy a Jackson County pristine wooded wetland, and also require huge amounts of groundwater for its operation:
1. This is just the latest example of Wisconsin right-wing GOP Gov. and corporate tool Scott Walker and his party helping the private sector absorb public resources in a loop of mutual self-interest across multiple business interests:
...the Walkerites have used law and policy and political power in Wisconsin - - this GOP/corporate control has been an under-covered, carefully crafted take-over operation - - to tilt benefits and access in a heavenly way towards big business and the executives who own them.
2. There are records of $10,300 in campaign donations from the land owner and people associated with it to Walker's campaign, according to this report by the Wisconsin Democracy Campaign.
3. Projects like this will probably accelerate in Wisconsin and elsewhere because Walker is lobbying Donald Trump to give states more control over environmental policy-and-decision making, and because Trump has named former pro-business Oklahoma Attorney General Scott Pruitt as administrator of the US Environmental Protection Agency.
Walker had Wisconsin join Pruitt as an anti-EPA litigant fighting federal clean air rules.
3/8 Update: Trump is adding more enemies of climate science and EPA mission to senior EPA positions, reports The New York Times.
Mr. Pruitt has drawn heavily from the staff of his friend and fellow Oklahoma Republican, Senator James Inhofe, long known as Congress’s most prominent skeptic of climate science.
A former Inhofe chief of staff, Ryan Jackson, will be Mr. Pruitt’s chief of staff. Another former Inhofe staff member, Byron Brown, will serve as Mr. Jackson’s deputy.
Andrew Wheeler, a fossil fuel lobbyist and a former Inhofe chief of staff, is a finalist to be Mr. Pruitt’s deputy, although he requires confirmation to the position by the Senate.
And as Trump and his budget slashers take aim at climate change science, staff and expertise at the EPA, and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and even the Centers for Disease Control, remember that Walker and his DNR did it first.
And let's look at some of the earlier record and precedents:
* Scott Pruitt, meet Cathy Stepp.
In a burst of uncharacteristic transparency days before becoming Wisconsin Governor, Scott Walker said he was nominating developer and outspoken Department of Natural Resources critic Cathy Stepp as agency Secretary because he wanted this critical Wisconsin environmental and management department with an open government/public health/clean water and air mission run with "a chamber of commerce mentality."
[Update] Other division-level and senior managers have come from the forestry industry, the builders organizations, transportation and the statewide chamber of commerce, summarized here. In fact, the Wisconsin Builders Association bragged about how closely their staff worked with key DNR insiders to get the bill written.
And here are the consequences: an agency with a severely damaged mentality, and reputation, according to insiders.
* Jackson County wetland, meet one in Brown County.
Walker was sworn in as Wisconsin Governor on January 3, 2011 - - five days after announcing his selection of Steps to run the DNR - - and nine days later he suspended the review of a wetland filling permit application so one of his campaign donors could more quickly begin building a project near Lambeau Field.
A companion bill introduced at Walker's request sped through the Legislature his party controlled.
[Update] A year later, Walker signed in front of cheering Realtors at their convention a bill which weakened environmental protections for wetlands.
As to campaign donations and environmental issues?
* Major Walker campaign donor Herb Kohler is working with the DNR on a plan to allow Kohler to turn a 247-acre wooded/wetland/artifact-rich nature preserve into a golf course along Lake Michigan.
The plan would even require four acres of an adjoining, popular state park to be included in the privately-owned, high end golf course project.
The agency is being so helpful to the golf course proponent that it hasn't yet required the submission of a formal permit application that would greatly inform the public and expand the record - - so right there is some DNR provided, one-sided, taxpayer-paid advantage and assistance - - but the DNR did discuss whether to discipline a DNR staffer for giving opponents some public information relevant to the matter.
Does all this sound even-handed and equitable to you?
* A major lead paint maker was found to have donated $750,000 to committees tied to Walker and GOP legislators before and after the GOP-controlled Legislature rolled back lead paint manufacturers' liability responsibilities.
* Another $700,000 was routed secretly to Walker's campaign by an out-of-state mining company for whom Walker signed sweetheart legislation written with the company's participation to allow the digging of a gigantic open pit mine measured in miles across the Bad River watershed and Penokee Hills in Northwest Wisconsin.
Again, does this sound equitable?
The mine proposal fell through because, as critics and the neighboring Ojibwe tribe had repeatedly argued and documented, there was too much water in the area for the mine to be established.
* A wealthy couple who had donated more than $3 million to various Walker-related campaign organizations received DNR approval to buy a prime piece of state lake frontage; public pressure blocked the deal until an alternative arrangement was approved.
Also, the DNR, with assists from Wisconsin's corporately-attuned GOP Attorney General and State Supreme Court majority whose campaign committees have received millions of dollars in donations from Walker-sympathetic business and conservative advocacy organizations has loosened the rules governing high-volume well pumping permits which supply water to diary and farming and frackers sand operations - - but which can deplete nearby waters, as is well-known.
Records show Walker's campaign has received more than $30,000 from two of the most recent big-volume ground water permit winners:
One of the permits was granted to James Wysocki, of Bancroft, for a well located in Pine Grove in Portage County. Wysocki and several members of his family own the Wysocki Family of Companies, which operates large vegetable and dairy farms.
The owners of the Wysocki Family of Companies contributed about $31,000 to Walker between January 2010 and August 2016...
And GOP legislators are getting ready to further loosen high-volume well permitting procedures.
In summary:
This is going to be the pattern in Wisconsin and across the country - - as I have noted here and here - - when Walker and similarly chamber-of-commerce minded Governors get more environmental power from the EPA which Trump will run with a chamber of commerce mentality.
Don't think for a moment that National Parks and other public lands can't go the way of Wisconsin state park acreage a Walker donor wants for his golf course, or the 10,000 acres of state land the Wisconsin GOP-controlled Legislature arbitrarily had the DNR put on the market - - along with permissions for Walker to sell any state asset, up to and including power plants, campus dorms, and the State Capitol.
All part and parcel of running government with "a chamber of commerce mentality."
You probably heard that right-wing WI Gov. and pollution-enabler Scott Walker's "chamber of commerce mentality" management at the intentionally-diminished Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources scrubbed climate science information
from the agency's main web page about the causes of climate change and its effects on the Great Lakes.
And I got to thinking that just because Walker and his hand-picked agency Secretary and mission-killer Cathy Stepp withhold critical data and useful links to information from the people shouldn't mean that we can't create resources that might even improve on those which our state-paid censors have deleted.
So here's a first draft of A Wisconsin Citizen's Guide to Climate Change
Suggestions welcomed. Expect updates:
-----------------------------------------------
* Climate.nasa.gov
Multiple studies published in peer-reviewed scientific journals1 show that 97 percent or more of actively publishing climate scientists agree: Climate-warming trends over the past century are extremely likely due to human activities. In addition, most of the leading scientific organizations worldwide have issued public statements endorsing this position.
* ClimateWisconsin.org
Climate Wisconsin is an educational multimedia project featuring stories of climate change. All stories are supported by research conducted in collaboration with the Wisconsin Initiative on Climate Change Impacts. Background essays and teaching tips were developed with support from the Nelson Institute for Environmental Studiesand Center for Biology Education at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Climate Wisconsin is a project of the Educational Communications Boardwith funding from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting.
* Yale Program on Climate Change Communication:
We conduct scientific studies on public opinion and behavior; inform the decision-making of governments, media, companies, and advocates; educate the public about climate change; and help build public and political will for climate action.
* ClimateCentral.org
An independent organization of leading scientists and journalists researching and reporting the facts about our changing climate and its impact on the public.
* Clean Wisconsin:
Key Points about Climate Change
- Wisconsin’s climate is changing, due primarily to pollution caused by burning fossil fuels for energy.
- Wisconsin’s communities need to act in order to prepare for the coming climate change impacts.
- In Wisconsin, climate change will lead to more severe weather, increased droughts, increased floods, damage to ecosystems like forests and stress on farm crops and livestock, raising the cost of food.
- Climate change will strain populations of fish and wildlife, reducing certain hunting and fishing opportunities in Wisconsin.
- Climate change will adversely impact public health in Wisconsin by increasing the incidence and severity of air pollution and water-borne and vector-borne diseases.
- Actions to reduce global warming pollution can still help to prevent the most dangerous consequences of climate change.
* Wisconsin Initiative on Climate Change Impacts:
Wisconsin's climate has changed since 1950. The average temperature for the whole state has risen by roughly 1.0–1.5 deg. F. The rise has been uneven: northwestern parts of Wisconsin have warmed by roughly 2.0 deg. F; southern and northeastern parts have not warmed much, if at all. Temperature changes also differ by season. Winter and spring have warmed more than summer and fall. Nighttime low temperatures have risen more than have daytime highs.
These changes are reflected in Wisconsin's growing seasons. Since 1950, the growing season has become between one and four weeks longer in different parts of Wisconsin. North central and far northwestern regions have seen the greatest growing season increases. Winter has become correspondingly shorter. Lakes freeze later and thaw earlier on average now than they did in the past. These changes are reflected in plant and animal communities. Spring birds arrive earlier today than in the past. Spring plants bloom earlier. Gardeners are seeing shifts in plant hardiness zones.
* League of Conservation Voters:
LCV’s top priority is to address climate change – the greatest challenge of our generation. Climate change is happening now, and it poses a disproportionate threat to low-income communities and communities of color. We must swiftly transition to a clean energy economy that works for all our communities, reduce the harmful pollution created by burning fossil fuels, and invest in strategies that help us prepare for the impacts of climate change, many of which are already underway.
* The continuing reporting by veteran Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reporter Lee Berguist. A recent sample:
In a shift from the practice of two other state agencies, Wisconsin emergency management officials have released new information on climate change and its implications for the state.
In a report that it posted online last week, the state Division of Emergency Management devoted extensive attention to climate change and how a warming planet could spur natural disasters such as floods, drought and forest fires.
* Midwest Environmental Advocates:
There are federal Clean Air Act and corresponding state regulations for the six most common pollutants: ground level ozone, particulate matter, carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxide, sulfur dioxide, and lead. Other chemicals are regulated through state permits. Short term exposure to these and other air-borne chemicals can cause mild headaches and irritation. Long term exposures, or exposure to high levels of the chemicals, can lead to an increased risk of cancer, aggravated asthma, and neurological problems.
Wisconsin’s air pollution control regulations begin with the minimum requirements established by the Clean Air Act...
Air pollution is difficult to monitor, difficult to regulate and difficult to enforce. Midwest Environmental Advocates works to uphold state and federal air quality standards, but also uses the law in strategic ways to keep polluters from dirtying our air.
* The Washington Post's Weather Gang site. A recent sample:
The Arctic is so warm and has been this warm for so long that scientists are struggling to explain it and are in disbelief. The climate of the Arctic is known to oscillate wildly, but scientists say this warmth is so extreme that humans surely have their hands in it and may well be changing how it operates.
Temperatures are far warmer than ever observed in modern records, and sea ice extent keeps setting record lows.
* Nelson Institute for Environmental Studies, including:
* The Center for Climatic Research explores the past, present and future of the Earth's climate system and is a world leader in studies of climate history, ocean-atmosphere-biosphere interactions, and future climate at local, regional and global scales.
* United Nations climate science website:
There is a strong scientific consensus that the global climate is changing and that human activity contributes significantly to this trend. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s (IPCC) Fifth Assessment Report concludes, with 95 per cent certainty that
the human influence on the climate system is clear and is evident from the increasing greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere, positive radiative forcing, observed warming, and understanding of the climate system.
* Anything written by Andrew Revkin, now at ProPublica:
Andrew Revkin is the senior reporter for climate and related issues at ProPublica. He joined the newsroom in December 2016, after 21 years of writing for The New York Times, most recently through his Dot Earth blog for the Opinion section, and six years teaching at Pace University.
Revkin began writing on climate change in the 1980s. In the mid 2000s, he exposed political suppression of climate findings at NASA and editing of federal climate reports by political appointees with ties to the petroleum industry. He was the first Times reporter to file stories and photos from the sea ice around the North Pole.
* WisconsinWatch.org projects at Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism:
Mercury taints the fish. Nitrates, pesticides and endocrine disruptors are seeping into private well water. Trout streams are running dry. In this series, the Center is examining the many threats to Wisconsin’s water supply and water quality.
* My blog, The Political Environment, now ten years old with 17,835 posts, of which 2,044 reference the DNR and 685 discuss climate change science, including this recent example:
Climate change censors driven by science denial and obeisance to polluters these days at the GOP-managed, Scott Walker-redefined "chamber of commerce mentality" Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources are at it again.
Not content with having already stripped content and links from an agency webpage about climate change - - deletions I documented some years ago and which I have frequently referenced - - the ideologues intent on scrubbing science off these pages and sowing doubt and confusion about the consensus view of experts worldwide about climate change have edited, deleted and otherwise compressed to whitewash long-standing concepts and facts off a climate change page about the Great Lakes.
The same way, I will add, that Walker edited and watered-down the Wisconsin Idea, which has for decades had been the University system's historic mission statement.
The US EPA's climate change website: Copy now before Trump's agency killer Scott Pruitt and the Office of Management and Budget follow the Walker/Stepp Wisconsin model and begin a deep agency cleansing:
Why is the climate changing?
How is the climate changing?
What can we do about this change?
Look what came in the mail today.
Keep subscribing!
Force Walker and the DNR to snub 90,000 subscribers who provide 100% of the popular magazine's costs by going through with his budget plan to kill the magazine.
State legislators and environmental organizations: where are you on this issue that Walker has gifted us?