Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Golden Sands. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Golden Sands. Sort by date Show all posts

Thursday, January 9, 2020

Lawsuit against one WI CAFO gets bigger. The issues are significant and statewide.

Large-scale animal feeding operations in Wisconsin are proliferating. So are efforts to rein them in.

This blog has posted about large Wisconsin animal feeding operations and groundwater contamination issues for years - - here, or here, or here - - and an expanding lawsuit aimed at one large operator shows why neighbors public have had enough:
About 200 households suing large farms in Wood and Juneau counties
According to the complaint, the Central Sands Dairy Farm, a Wysocki Family of Farms partner, reportedly has 6,165 animals that produce 37,500,200 gallons of liquid manure and wastewater, and 14,472 tons of solid manure annually. Reportedly, 50 million gallons of liquid waste and 26,000 tons of solid waste annually from those animals and other sources are spread on fields in the central sands area. 
Keep in mind that Wisconsin has more than 200 of these so-called CAFOS (Concentrated animal Feeding operations), and the political protection they have received from entrenched GOP politicians has strengthened as their numbers have accelerated:

Vos, Fitzgerald go to bat for 'existing and expanding CAFO operations'
Also: 
* The central sands area is a known center of groundwater contamination. 
I included in a July 9 summary blog post about water pollution statewide
CAFO runoff in Kewaunee County, NW WI
key recent findings of groundwater contamination in Juneau County, including the Towns of Armenia and Port Edwards: 
* Widespread well water contamination reported in Juneau County.
Testing of more than 100 water wells in a rural area of Juneau County found 42 percent of them had high levels of nitrates and nitrogen, making the water unsafe to drink, a groundwater specialist said Tuesday.
* A separate, proposed Wysocki project - - Golden Sands - - is involved in a high profile legal case. 

Note that national media have written about the issues: 
It’s a particular problem in the middle of the state where Golden Sands has been proposed. The region, called Central Sands, was formed by a glacial lake, leaving behind the Wisconsin River as a souvenir. A quarter of this flat, broad landscape is now devoted to agriculture.
Wysocki has said "legacy" farming practices could be to blame:
Wysocki did not respond to HuffPost’s requests for comment on the lawsuit. However, Tim Huffcutt, a spokesperson for Wysocki Family of Companies, sent a statement to the USA Today Network-Wisconsin in January, saying, “there are various sources of nitrates in the environment” and repeating suggestions that these could be linked to legacy farming practices. Huffcutt’s statement also said the Armenia Growers Coalition believes providing bottled water and treatment systems “is the best way forward.”
The WI DNR's website says that proposed operation does not yet have a current permit: 
August 2019 status
The permit applications and supporting documents submitted by the Golden Sands Dairy LLC were considered incomplete. The department has placed the permit review and the environmental impact statement process on hold and is not actively working on the project review.  
The department will update this webpage and send notification via GovDelivery, if and when the department receives updated permit application materials from the applicant.
* Wysocki interests have been major lobbying spenders and some of its personnel have been campaign donors, especially to Walker, according to Wisconsin Democracy Campaign.





Monday, April 25, 2016

DNR wants more well monitoring at Central Sands CAFO, but...

[Updated from 1:15 p.m. Monday] Groundwater in the Wisconsin's central sands region is both over-pumped and contaminated at high levels by animal waste runoff, but officials have been unable or unwilling to stop it.
File:Confined-animal-feeding-operation.jpg
Several large animal-feeding operations known as CAFO's (Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations) are under review by the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources, including a 26,000-pig feeding CAFO - - the largest of its kind in Wisconsin - - which Iowa owners want to locate in NW WI near the City of Ashland and within smelling distance of Lake Superior.

Draft permit documents newly-posted by the DNR show that the the Central Sands CAFO operation in Juneau County - - one of the state's most controversial - - will be required through changes in its DNR-issued operating permit to install additional monitoring wells and other improvements on-site.

The proposed permit modifications will not require that groundwater meet designated quality standards - - as sought often by concerned citizens - - which continues a trend and recent state actions which also required a huge Kewaunee County dairy cattle CAFO to add more groundwater monitoring - - but which also allowed the operator to substantially expand the CAFO's capacity even though a state administrative law judge had put a cap on it.

A public comment period about the Central Sands CAFO permit modifications, and a two-hour hearing on the matter will be held in the Necedah village hall on May 9th, from 1:30-3:30 p.m.

Here's a 2015 newspaper story with some of the Juneau County/Central Sands CAFO's history and information about another big CAFO - - Golden Sands - - which has been proposed in Wood County by the same owner as Central Sands, and is still under a DNR review:
...a report filed in August with the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources that shows monitoring wells at Central Sands Dairy, in the town of Armenia in Juneau County, recently contained nitrate levels substantially higher than state drinking water standards. 
...groundwater tests of four wells at Central Sands Dairy found nitrogen levels ranging widely — some far below state standards, but other tests that indicated nitrogen levels well above what the state considers safe. 
Tests in one well showed nitrogen levels at 77 parts per million in July, an increase from 60 parts per million in December. The state considers nitrate levels above 10 parts per million unsafe, particularly for infants...Testing also showed the presence of E. Coli in two wells, and levels of ammonium exceeding a lower standard of concern.
More about those CAFOs and their common ownership, here:

Below are the links to the new DNR documents about the Central Sands CAFO, and some excerpts:

http://dnr.wi.gov/topic/wastewater/documents/central-sands-modfs.pdf

Central Sands Dairy LLC is a currently Wisconsin Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (WPDES)-permitted dairy Concentrated Animal Feeding Operation. Its current WPDES permit became effective on January 1, 2012 and will expire on December 31, 2016. At issuance, the operation housed approximately 3800 dairy cows and 400 calves, or 5300 Animal Units. In response to concerns about potential groundwater impacts associated with the operation’s production area, the Department is proposing to modify the current permit to include requirements for Central Sands Dairy LLC to install a production area groundwater monitoring system... 
Reasons: The Department is modifying the WPDES Permit for Central Sands Dairy to require additional groundwater monitoring for the reasons listed here. Additional information is in the attached report from the Drinking Water and Groundwater Program dated March 31, 2016. 
A. The above listed submittals from Central Sands Dairy included new information that a septic system drain field exists immediately upgradient from the groundwater monitoring well nest CSD-1. 
B. The Department has reviewed the production area groundwater monitoring results submitted to date, and finds that additional groundwater monitoring locations are needed to identify the source or sources of groundwater contamination. The monitoring results to date do not support, Central Sands Dairy's position that the causes are from off-site, and possibly from on-site limited facilities that the WPDES Permit does not regulate (a septic system drain field) or that are no longer in use (a feed runoff treatment infiltration strip). 
C. Central Sands Dairy performed what it refers to as a "comprehensive integrity analysis" ofthe manure storage lagoon, which included emptying, cleaning, and inspection, and repair ofthe cracks identified. The Department believes most ofthe cracks were narrow enough that significant liquid leakage seems unlikely. Unfortunately, soil samples taken from below the cracks did not receive chemical testing to help determine if leakage had occurred. Also, Central Sands Dairy has still not acknowledged the groundwater found within 2 feet below the floor elevation at the time of repair, and the analysis also did not address this finding. This groundwater found was mentioned only in a field note, with no photos or resulting soil test results provided, and no other information or mention ofthis groundwater elevation was made in the analysis report (prepared by AECOM). 
D. The Department and Central Sands Dairy have determined the digester floor elevation appears to not have the required minimum 2 feet from saturation, based on the groundwater level monitoring results from groundwater monitoring wells, and the digester design plans (no as-built record is available). 
E. The Department does not agree that the manure lagoon and digester were in compliance with the minimum required separation to saturation specified by the NRCS 313 Standard in effect at the time of construction. (September 28, 2015, Non-Compliant Evaluation letter from the Department).
http://dnr.wi.gov/topic/wastewater/documents/central-sands-mod_perm.pdf

Also - - the number of CAFOs statewide has gone from 50 to more than 200 since 2000, according to DNR data:

CAFO Graph

Wednesday, December 7, 2016

Big WI CAFO ginormous manure yield

I noted yesterday that Wisconsin GOP Gov. Scott Walker's 'chamber of commerce mentality' Department of Natural Resources could approve several major water-demanding and environmentally-destructive projects - - including a 26,000-feeding operation in NW Wisconsin, a high-end golf course slapped into a rare sand dune-and-artifact rich nature preserve adjoining and intruding into Kohler Andrae State Park south of Sheboygan along Lake Michigan and a massive dairy operation in the state's central sands Wood County ironically named Golden Sands by the family of Walker donors proposing it.
File:Confined-animal-feeding-operation.jpg
One recent news story gives you an idea of how not-so-golden that Wood County site could become, and why local officials there, anticipating a DNR green light, are trying to enact some local land and water use controls:
The proposed Golden Sands Dairy would house 5,300 animals, and produce 55 million gallons of liquid manure and 25,000 tons of solid manure each year...
The town has been involved in legal action with the Wysocki Family of Companies, owner of Golden Sands, since 2012...
The new ordinance points to groundwater monitoring wells near the existing Central Sands Dairy in Juneau County, which is also owned by Wysocki.

Wednesday, September 21, 2016

Golden Sands CAFO info/hearing likely after Nov. election

Despite the news story to the contrary below, I am hearing - - and not for the first time - - that this hot potato will be held until after the November elections:

Saratoga CAFO report could be released soon



A long-awaited report about a controversial dairy farm that could be built in southern Wood County may soon be released.

The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources tentatively plans to issue a draft environmental impact statement about the proposed Golden Sands Dairy by the end of September, a senior DNR official told state legislators Wednesday.

The DNR also is tentatively planning to hold a public hearing in late October, although both dates are subject to change...

Golden Sands Dairy would have 5,300 cows and is expected to produce 55 million gallons of liquid manure each year, according to the DNR. The farm also would have 33 high-capacity wells, each of which has the capacity to draw more than 100,000 gallons of water per day.

If it occurs, the delay is likely related to the political problems caused statewide by CAFO runoff, additional pollution from millions of gallons of CAFO manure spread by aerosol spray on nearby farms, CAFOs' heavy groundwater demands and several other issues causing political problems for GOP legislators. 

It would also not surprise me if Walker tries to minimize coverage that plays into the big-money, speciall-interest "supplicant" label The Washington Post dropped on him in the wake of The Guardian's document dump.


The Wisconsin Democracy Campaign has tracked more than $30,000 in donations from the CAFO's owners to Walker's campaign.
File:Confined-animal-feeding-operation.jpg
Here's a longer list of those hot potatoes which Walker's 'chamber of commerce mentality;-driven DNR has on its plate.

Thursday, June 30, 2016

Manure spreaders also spread cash into Walker's campaigns

I've posted any number of items about the private-interest focus of Scott Walker's "chamber of commerce" Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources - - one summary among many, here - - from the agency's loss of mission to its dismissal of clean water responsibilities to the damage it enables through minimally-regulated, expanding industrial-scale feedlots which overdraw the groundwater and pollute what remains.

But this headline and report by the Wisconsin Democracy Campaign is the most timely summation of the pollution which flows from the Governor's office through the DNR and right into people's land and well water in our fouled state.
Factory Farm Owners in Manure Case Gave Walker $30,000+ 
June 29, 2016
The owners of the factory farm that was recently cleared of violating state environmental rules for spreading manure gave more than $30,000 to Republican Gov. Scott Walker over the last six years. 
Earlier this year, Central Sands Dairy, with 3,800 cows, spread large amounts of liquid manure on 200 acres it owns near homes and a trout stream in the town of Grant. Some of it was spread even with rain in the forecast, according to Madison attorney Christa Westerberg, who contacted the DNR on behalf of area residents. But the Department of Natural Resources said the farm did not violate the law. Central Sands Dairy is owned by the Wysocki Family of Companies, which also wants to build a controversial factory farm called Golden Sands Dairy in Saratoga in Wood County.
Four years ago, rural Wisconsin got its first nasty taste of this intentional Walker/DNR approach:
A waste hauler avoids referral by DNR staffers to prosecutors for egregious human waste dumping near wells and farm fields. 
Turns out in Walker World if you're in that kind of trouble, it doesn't hurt to know the political appointees he put in charge of the DNR, or a well-connected sitting legislator, too,


Wednesday, November 16, 2016

Awaiting state, federal moves on WI water, land issues

Just a reminder that Scott Walker's intentionally degraded and special-interest managed 'chamber of commerce mentality' Department of Natural Resources is still reviewing several environmentally-sensitive and politically-influenced high-profile proposals.

Now that the election is over, and DNR Secretary Cathy Stepp is off the Trump speaking circuit and can devote full-time to her day job and clean up missed deadlines and other reporting issues, I'd expect some movement on these controversial plans, though potential litigation as well as input from local officials, the US Army Corps of Engineers and the US Environmental Protection Agency could mean that DNR actions and decisions can't be considered final.


*  An upscale, privately-owned eighteen hole golf course proposed by the Kohler Co. on a 247-acre water, dune and Native American artifact-rich wooded nature preserve adjoining Kohler Andrae State Park south of Sheboygan. The plan includes some intrusion into the park, and is further complicated by the company's refusal to submit a formal proposal which the DNR, other agencies and the public could then focus on with precision.



*  A 26,000-hog feeding and manure producing operation within smelling distance of Lake Superior in NW Wisconsin proposed by a major Iowa pork provider. It would be the largest hog operation in Wisconsin and there is organizing against it in the same areas where opponents helped kill a proposed 22-mile long, half-a-mile-wide open-pit iron ore mine.


*  An expansion of the Golden Sands Dairy cattle feeding and manure producing operation in Juneau and Wood Counties. Again, opponents have been raising crucial land, air and water pollution concerns.


All of these proposals will have impacts on ground and surface water quality and supply levels - - statewide health and equity matters so significant that the US Environmental Protection Agency just paid a record-checking visit to the DNR after citizen and organizations' complaints catalogued the Walker administration's studious dismissal of state water obligations under federal clean water law.


A public session this week in Eau Claire on the state's water law enforcement record  may lead to either remedial federal-mandated actions or state promises to do a better job - - and it is not clear how such outcomes could affect the big projects under DNR review.


Update: Here is one media account of the Eau Claire meeting.

So stay tuned. And involved.


Monday, February 10, 2014

Dairy Expansions, Groundwater De-Regulation Roiling The Dairy State

Dairy expansions statewide, multiple court cases and the Legislature's meddling in groundwater protections on behalf of special-interest big users all highlight the growing ascension of corporate power in state government at the expense of citizens' rights to clean water and peace of mind.

* Neighbors of a Kewaunee County mega-dairy set to expand by more than 50% finally get their say at a Green Bay hearing on Tuesday - - but after the DNR has approved the permit. 

The Cap Times ran a solid investigative report about it Saturday, here.

I'd put up information about the hearing and the issues last week:

At the center of the dispute is the dairy's plan, OK'ed by the DNR, to store and then spread up to 70 million gallons of liquid manure and other livestock waste. 
The approval process - - detailed here - - illustrates everything that is wrong at the DNR  - - traditionally a neutral, honest-broker natural resources agency - -  that is now directed by senior managers from the Wisconsin private sector implementing Scott Walker's self-described "chamber-of-commerce mentality." 
Why should everyday Wisconsin citizens have to raise and spend their own limited funds to fight not only the neighboring big dairy over clean water and environmental protection, but also take on the DNR itself - - a state agency supported by those same citizens' income taxes? 
Citizens who are not getting taxation with representation; in fact, their having to hire lawyers is like being taxed a second time to get a job done that the DNR should be doing on the citizens' behalf. 
A job it continues to let slide.
* And multiple cases along the same lines are surfacing in central Wisconsin:
While court cases continue to move forward on a proposed large-scale dairy in Saratoga, Wisconsin legislators work on a way to resolve issues with the high-capacity well approval process.  
A lawsuit the owners of the proposed Golden Sands dairy filed against Saratoga’s building inspector is in the appeals process. A lawsuit the owners filed against the town is still in Wood County Circuit Court. The Wysocki Family of Companies, which proposed the dairy, has filed an application for 49 high-capacity wells in Saratoga, and the wells are still in the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resource’s, application process.

Wednesday, August 1, 2018

In Flint crisis, Gov. Snyder, others escape liability

Get out of jail free cards are being handed out across Lake Michigan.

Great news for Republicans in Michigan, where you can be a government official  with a role in a mass poisoning and a judge just said you're not liable!
Judge dismisses Gov. Snyder, state from Flint water class action lawsuit
Rick Snyder in 2013.jpg
This escape from personal responsibility when doing the people's business you took an oath to steward wisely fits nicely with the current Republican principle-free narrative in Wisconsin where Walker and his agencies and allies and donors are so done with private property rights, public property preservation, local control, Nixon-era clean air and water protections and other pesky, legacy beliefs and practices ignored or trashed, literally.

An ominous development with toxic metallic mining getting ever closer in Michigan, and this is on the Wisconsin border:
Back 40 Mine Gets Final Permit
At its deepest point, the open pit mine could be 750 feet and roughly 2,200 feet long. The mine’s total surface area is expected to be about 83 acres. Also, the mine’s closest point to the Menominee River would be about 150 feet. 
I guess all that's left to complete this circle of contamination would be giving Snyder the Golden Water Filter Award. Lifetime Achievement category.

Walker awaiting his.
WI Central Sands the next Flint? Kewaunee County already soaking up that honor.