Wednesday, June 26, 2013

More Proof That DNR = NRA + WMC

Money is so easy in Wisconsin these days that the DNR says it will help you build a shooting range:

Shooting Range Grant Program announced
DNR to provide $325,000 in cost share for projects at private ranges MADISON -- More and higher-quality shooting opportunities for the public are expected thanks to a state cost-share grant program for public and private shooting ranges announced this week by the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources.  -  Read Full Article
The Shooting Range Grant Program can cost share up to 50 percent of approved renovation and development costs at private ranges and up to 75 percent at publicly owned ranges. Counties, cities, villages, townships, other governmental agencies or units, clubs or organizations, businesses or corporations and educational institutions are eligible for this program. The $325,000 is available for projects on privately owned ranges. Publicly owned range projects will be evaluated and funded on a case by case basis and will not affect the amount of money available for the grant program. 
I'd call it the Hunter Vote Roundup Grant Program.

Argle-Bargle Alert: Justice Scalia Discovers Gay Rights Cheeky Threats

"Argle-Bargle."

Bollocks.

Texas Legislator Proves One Person Can Make A Difference

Wendy Davis, role model:

You know, the Fort Worth Democrat who stood for eleven hours to filibuster a bill in the Texas State Senate that would place new restrictions on abortion clinics and ban the practice after 20 weeks of pregnancy? Here’s what you need to know. [UPDATE: She stood long enough to kill the bill, Texas' Lieutenant Governor ruled at 3:01 a.m.]

Best Outcome In WI From High Court's Pro-Gay Rights' Rulings...

Eventual removal of overtly discriminatory 2006 state constitutional ban to gay marriage and civil union.

Remember that it was the brainchild of John Gard, and had the backing of Scott Walker.

Blog Guide To WI Water, Mining, Rail Issues

I get requests from time to time for links and posts about various environmental issues central to recent Wisconsin politics, so here a few basic entry points:

The GTAC iron ore mine:
The Iron Mine: Planning, Technology And Human Behavior
A 2012 mining archive:
For You Archivists Out There - - Some Recent Mining Posts
Water Crisis:
Wisconsin Waters At Crisis PointRail:
In Job Poor State, Walker Derailed Wisconsin's Emerging Rail Industry

Tuesday, June 25, 2013

Important Presidential Moves On Climate Change

* Directly addressing climate change, and greenhouse gas emissions:

...Obama's most prominent effort yet to deliver on a major priority he laid out in his first presidential campaign and recommitted to at the start of his second term: to fight climate change in the U.S. and abroad and prepare American communities for its effects. Environmental activists have been irked that Obama's high-minded goals never materialized into a comprehensive plan. 
By expanding permitting on public lands, Obama hopes to generate enough electricity from renewable energy projects such as wind and solar to power the equivalent of 6 million homes by 2020, effectively doubling the electric capacity federal lands now produce. He also set a goal to install 100 megawatts of energy-producing capacity at federal housing projects by the end of the decade. 
Obama also announced $8 billion in federal loan guarantees to spur investment in technologies that can keep carbon dioxide produced by power plants from being released into the atmosphere.
*  Using executive actions:

Embracing an issue that could define his legacy but also ignite new battles with Republicans, Mr. Obama said he would use his executive powers to require reductions in the amount of carbon dioxide emitted by the nation’s power plants. That was the centerpiece of a three-part plan that includes new federal spending to advance renewable energy technology, as well as spending to protect cities and states from the ravages of storms and droughts that are exacerbated by a changing climate.

WASHINGTON -- President Barack Obama will ask the State Department not to approve the construction of the controversial Keystone XL pipeline unless it can first determine that it will not lead to a net increase in greenhouse gas emissions, a senior administration official told The Huffington Post. 

"Allowing the Keystone pipeline to be built requires a finding that doing so would be in our nation's interest," the president said in a Tuesday speech on climate change. "And our national interest will be served only if this project does not significantly exacerbate the problem of carbon pollution. The net effects of the pipeline's impact on our climate will be absolutely critical to determining whether this project is allowed to go forward."

Weakening Voting Rights Act Strengthens Voter ID, Other Curbs

Unfettered ballot access in America from sea-to-shining-sea? Not today, or for the foreseeable future.

The US Supreme Court, 5-4, has decided to weaken a section of The Voting Rights Act and let southern and southwestern states with a history of discrimination evade the needed scrutiny that had helped to ensure unfettered ballot access.


Big mistake, not only because racial and ethnic discrimination is alive and well in those states and across the country but because it will embolden voter-suppression friendly legislators and Governors in states like Wisconsin to add ID, registration and early/absentee voting restrictions that block minorities, students and lower-income citizens from fair, simple ballot access.

Not as overtly as poll taxes and literacy tests, but enough to penalize certain groups and swing elections. The politics of these issues pushed by conservative and partisan GOP interests is undeniable.

The country just cannot escape its past; the Court can't or won't recognize America, 2013, nor will a Congress where the Tea Party rules the House.

And both the Court and much of Congress operates by design and reflex the way that people in power, and especially those threatened by a more diverse electorate are wont to do,  refusing to let go of a scintilla of authority and control without scheming and fighting - - all undermining the democracy that keeps failing to measure up to high-falutin' words and ideals in old documents.

Recent Kid Shooters, 2nd Amendment Sadnesses

In Louisiana:

5-year-old girl in New Orleans dies from self-inflicted gunshot wound
In New Jersey:
Father arrested in his 4-year-old son's shooting of neighbor
In Tennessee: 
Woman killed by 4-year-old in Tennessee cookout







Monday, June 24, 2013

WI Bail Bondsman Scheme Based On A Falsehood

When you control the process, facts are irrelevant, but, seriously, what kind of a state are we becoming:

The Truth-O-Meter Says:

Vos

A study of private bail bond systems "showed that Wisconsin has a higher no-show rate than other states" of defendants skipping court appearances.  

Robin Vos on Monday, June 10th, 2013 in an interview

Vos says study shows defendants skip court appearances more frequently in Wisconsin than in other states

Commenters On Iron Mine Not Afraid To Stereotype

Hat tip to Shakara Robinson for following closely the Brookfield rock waste dump story - - I'd linked to one of her earlier stories, here, and noted the ironic connections to the iron mine rock waste controversy Up North - - but it didn't take long for the comment section to go depressingly negative.

People have no inhibitions, it seems - - (I took out the identifying ID hotlinks because took you to Facebook, making others' pages visible):

....most of the permanent residents in Ashland and Iron County want the Mine, except those that pray to the fish gods, wind gods, tree gods and have no interest in working for a living where they may have to pay taxes because they finally earn enough to do so. Might have to pay for their phones, food and what ever entitlements they are receiving. There will be substantial improvements to that area, just like at our dead beat quarry. There always is that element. Those in charge have to look for the betterment of all in the area when the project is finished. Now watch our liberal media blow this whole idea out of proportion to the good it will do in the end for all of us. 

Poll: WI Residents Overwhelmingly Oppose Wolf Hunting, So...

The DNR is proposing to increase the allowable kill by 35%.

Conducted by Mason-Dixon Polling & Research, an independent polling firm based in Washington, D.C. and Jackonsville, Fl., for the polled 625 voters, via land lines and cell phones, from June 13 to June 15. 
The full results (PDF) detail gender and partisan breakdowns for six questions, along with regional and general demographics for respondents. 
The Humane Society is releasing the results of the survey in advance of the June 26 meeting (PDF) of the Natural Resources Board, which is scheduled to vote on a recommendation to increase the number of wolves hunted from 201 in 2012 to 275 in 2013....
According to the survey, 79% of those polled agreed that wolves are an asset and should be protected, while 14% disagreed and 7% were not sure. Eighty one percent opposed the "trophy hunting and trapping of wolves for sport," while 10% were in support and 9% were undecided. The margin of error is plus or minus 4 percent. 
What kind of representative government do we have here?

Fewer WI People On BadgerCare - - More $$ To Emergency Rooms

Thanks to great work at gothealthcarewi.com here are the human totals (and about 25% are in Milwaukee County):

Kicked off by County
POSTED BY KEVIN KANE ON JUNE 24, 2013 ·  
Last week, on the day of the Senate vote on the budget to ensure that it would fly under the radar, the Wisconsin Department of Health Services finally released the long-demanded breakdown of which counties would see individuals forced off of BadgerCare and how many. This list is broken down below. 
This also by itself does not even include the numbers of people who should have had access to BadgerCare had Wisconsin accepted the federal funds. We have long featured those numbers on our website. Together they reveal massive numbers of citizens that will continue to struggle to access healthcare when they didn't have to.

As GTAC Plans Waste Rock, Mine Debris Dumping For 35 Years, Consider...

What's happening right now to toxic waste and tailing dump sites in Tarsandia, Canada:

Fort McMurray, Home to 176 Square km of Tar Sands Tailings Ponds, Overwhelmed by Floods
More proof for the argument I made here about the GTAC mine's projected glorious operations and reclamation, even though the rock, containing acidic-producing elements, will be dumped in lakes, on a watershed, near rice-growing estuaries close to Lake Superior:
[Spokesman Bob] Seitz said the process would involve the creation of what would essentially be a large hill of mining tailings that would be covered over with earth and replanted at the conclusion of open-pit mining activities in the first stage. The second stage would dispose of its tailings in the first pit, while the second pit would, at the conclusion of its operational life, be turned into a 355-acre lake. That lake would be graded to produce gentle slopes, making it conducive to recreational uses.
And:
“Once you build that hill, you can cover a portion of it with topsoil, you can concurrently reclaim it, which means that you have a much smaller portion of the waste area that is open and by the time the process is complete, you are actually going to have mature trees or whatever the reclamation plan calls for,” Seitz said. 
Color me skeptical.

And skeptical, also, because of this:

MONDAY, JUNE 24, 2013


Check Out This Account Of Recent, Massive Open Pit Mine Slide

Since we're on the topic of open pit mine operation, safety, and planning right here in Wisconsin - - take note that there was in April the biggest landslide at a massive open pit copper mine in Utah in 36 years, and it began with movement measured in a fraction of an inch.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Aerial shot of landslide in Bingham Canyon copper-gold mine near Salty Lake City, Utah. Photo courtesy Kennecott Utah Copper via Facebook.

Anti-Milwaukee GOP Officials Enable Gun Criminals

Hard to believe, but Gov. Walker and GOP budget-writers chose not to include a mere $445,000 in a $68 billion state budget to fund an electronic gunshot tracing system for the City of Milwaukee.

Sticking it to the city couldn't get more grotesque.

The details, as reported by the Journal Sentinel:

ShotSpotter: The Legislature's Joint Finance Committee rejected an attempt to restore $445,400 from a community policing grant for the Police Department's ShotSpotter program. Walker had not included the money in his budget. 
The technology, in use in high-crime areas in the city, uses sensors to detect gunshots. 
"This is a very effective law enforcement tool," Barrett said. "They still took the money out."
And please do not call this "pork." It would have funded, at a modest level, a crime-fighting tool to help get guns and criminals off the streets. Pretty much Public Safety 101.

If you want to talk about pork, look at the $5 million budget amendment - - that's twelve times the amount of the ShotSpotter grant - - somehow miraculously approved for the hometown of a Joint Finance Committee co-chairman to assist a business development center.

I'm sure every district has some kind of similar operation.


Check Out This Account Of Recent, Massive Open Pit Mine Slide

Since we're on the topic of open pit mine operation, safety, and planning right here in Wisconsin - - take note that there was in April the biggest landslide at a massive open pit copper mine in Utah in 36 years, and it began with movement measured in a fraction of an inch.

Mine managers anticipated what section of the mine wall was likely to move, a surface area "a couple thousand feet wide" and just as tall, but the slide traveled deeper into the mine pit than they expected, Himebaugh said. 
Teams worked preemptively to clear out an old truck shop that was partially swept away, successfully limiting the damage. However, equipment left stationed at the bottom of the mine to help remove debris was caught and buried when the slide moved deeper than predicted. 
About two-thirds of the bottom of the pit was buried, Himebaugh estimated. 

Sunday, June 23, 2013

Weather Facts To Warm Up To

How about a recent 90 degrees at Valdez, Alaska, and 96 degrees near Mt. McKinley (Denali)?

The Iron Mine: Planning, Technology And Human Behavior

I'd noted yesterday a long piece about the most recent GTAC iron ore mine initial operating and reclamation plans, called it a must-read, and want to add a little context.

What I found so striking was the certainty with which the company asserted something of a sweeping New Penokee Hills Creation Story wherein miles of land and vegetation in existence for eons can be blown up, trucked out, milled, exported by rail, while massive amounts of waste rock are deposited on nearby land and waterways with people and communities close by...and then the entire area will be restored, even improved:

[Spokesman Bob] Seitz said the process would involve the creation of what would essentially be a large hill of mining tailings that would be covered over with earth and replanted at the conclusion of open-pit mining activities in the first stage. The second stage would dispose of its tailings in the first pit, while the second pit would, at the conclusion of its operational life, be turned into a 355-acre lake. That lake would be graded to produce gentle slopes, making it conducive to recreational uses.
And:
“Once you build that hill, you can cover a portion of it with topsoil, you can concurrently reclaim it, which means that you have a much smaller portion of the waste area that is open and by the time the process is complete, you are actually going to have mature trees or whatever the reclamation plan calls for,” Seitz said. 
Color me skeptical.

I remember example after example of glitzy, dreamy complex projects that began with engineers and politicians singing the plans' praises (along with their own) as they promised fail-safe designs and environmental safety and social successes, but events proved otherwise and at great, irreparable costs.

In other words, the exact opposite of what was promised, because plans are planned and outcomes, for a variety of reasons, go Code Red.

Such as:

*  Adequate sea walls protecting Japan's northern nuclear plants.

*  Trustworthy levees around New Orleans.

*  The Deepwater Horizon oil well in the Gulf of Mexico, with its super-duper blowout plug.

*  Three Mile Island.

*  Or on a smaller, local scale: look at the $800 million dollar Marquette Interchange project. It was planned, drafted, refined and modeled to death, all to defeat modest traffic congestion with modern designs - - yet the Marquette wasn't reopened for very long after four years of headaches before one elevated ramp's pillars began to disintegrate and more millions of dollars were spent reconfiguring westbound I-94 lanes that had produced...fresh congestion.

Granted that human beings are just that - - human. Bad things happen. Nothing and no one is perfect, even if the most highly-trained and experienced people are at the controls.

Literally.

Just about every aviation accident, despite numerous safety systems and redundancies, is related to or caused by human errors - - mistakes, poor judgements, bad policies or miscommunication. (I covered aviation safety for The Milwaukee Journal: the field is rich with information we can all understand and visualize about planning, technology, human behavior and risk).

This example always stuck with me:

Ninety-nine people died in 1972 when a Lockheed-1011, the most advanced large passenger jet flying at the time, crashed into the Florida Everglades because all three cockpit crew members, distracted by a single warning light (harmless, it turned out) as the plane descended towards the runway forgot to fly and land the plane.

True story.

Or fast forward to an airliner crash in 2006 at the airport in Lexington, KY that killed 49 people.

In a nutshell, the pilots launched their take-off roll down the wrong, too-short runway and crashed into trees and structures at the perimeter.

Sad, true story.

And even heroic pilots could not save an Alaska Air jetliner doomed because company policy called for infrequent lubrication of a key screw in the tail. One worn nut broke the screw assembly, the plane became unmanageable and 88 people fell to their deaths in the Pacific Ocean.

Inexplicably poor judgement at the help also led to a recent cruise ship disaster.

Getting the picture?

Mines to planes to ships; apples to oranges, you say?

How about this report from April of this year?



A landslide at Kennecott Utah Copper's Bingham Canyon Mine, which occurred Wednesday, April 10, 2013, is shown Thursday, April 11, 2013.
Ravell Call, Deseret News

BINGHAM CANYON — What started as movement measuring only fractions of an inch at Kennecott Utah Copper's Bingham Canyon Mine became the biggest slide Ted Himebaugh has seen in his 36 years with the company. 
Himebaugh, Kennecott's general manager of operation readiness, said the size and depth of the slide that occured Wednesday night is still unknown. After effectively preparing for the slide and preventing any injury, teams are beginning to assess its impact before they can determine when workers will return
.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
And projects are sold and advanced on science and data, but it's really a matter of how good is the information and how well is it turned, spin-free, into accurate predictions and workable, reliable policies.

The company planning the Keystone XL tar sands pipeline from Canada to Houston has predicted 11 major spills during its 50-year life - - bad enough, for sure - -  but one expert, using the company's data, says the number is really 91.

Average them out and you still get one a year. Google Kalamazoo River and see if you think US waters could take one of these annually.

Again, here's a local example where planning and data seem contradictory: when the Wisconsin Department of Transportation embarked nearly ten years ago on a 30-year, $6.4 billion plan to rebuild the Southeastern Wisconsin regional freeway system, and add 127 new lanes to absorb more miles driven, it relied on driving demand projections pegged to gasoline costing $2.30-per-gallon.

Before The Great Recession, and declines in driving due to generational changes, an aging population and people of all ages opting for walkable, transit-and-bike-friendly city settings.

But the new lanes are being added, with billions of dollars in the pipeline, across seven counties, as if we were in the middle of a driving binge fueled by cheap gasoline.

True story.

And it doesn't take much to defeat even the best-engineered systems that are brought online to implement the best laid plans that were supposed to unfold just as the predictions and brochures and politicos and corporate leaders promised.

Again, look to the proposed XL pipeline. A published report based on the company's information says small leaks could take as long as 90 days to be detected despite all the technology available.

And that's if the best-available practices are followed and advanced technologies are actually employed to make sure small leaks don't become bigger ones.

Speaking of which: There was a recent and major frac sand spill into the St. Croix River in Western Wisconsin by a mining operation that went undetected by company systems. A hiker discovered the torrent of polluting mud - - but not until the spill had run into the river for five days.

Yes, a true story.

So when we see that GTAC believes it can safely upend and then rebuild the Penokee Hills, with the Bad River Ojibwe and other communities' water supplies so closely downstream from the mining area, as I said - - call me a skeptic.

Maybe I'd give GTAC the benefit of the doubt if the Legislature and Gov. Walker hadn't changed state mining laws to meet the company's demands, fast-tracked the process and minimized citizen input.

Especially telling is how mining permit reviews and hearings would be run from now on.

Under the old law, citizens could raise challenges to the science, assumptions and information in the mining company's application before the DNR were to make a permit ruling.

The new law puts that public input perfunctorily into the process at a point after the permit decision is made.

If you were in court, how would you like to be able to introduce your evidence only after the judge announces a verdict?

We've seen that human beings can produce severely bad outcomes for large numbers of people due to the slightest, momentary mistake or seemingly minor equipment problem.

We know that Wisconsin waters are already are over-pumped and polluted - - but the powers that be are enabling mountain-top removal...for the excavation of a huge mine...needing giant amounts of fresh water...in a pristine watershed...where acid-bearing waste rock will be dumped for 35 years on open land and into lakes up to two acres in area...upstream from wild rice-bearing estuaries that have sustained the Bad River Ojibwe for centuries.

Approving a project this massive, this complex, this consequential, this risky - -and with data, assumption and conclusion vetting intentionally restricted when common sense says they should be expanded and honored is little more than an accident  - -  no, a predictable disaster - - waiting and guaranteed to happen.

And will put the mine on a world-class list of mistakes that occurred through avoidable human, political choices.














Saturday, June 22, 2013

It's Only An Online Poll, But Racism Is Leading, 60-40, Right Now

Journal Sentinel poll on the Food Network pulling the N-word devotee's cooking program. 60% don't favor the cancellation.

Update: An hour later, still 60-40.

Further Updates: Five hours later, 60-40.

At Midnight, 60-40.

24 hours later: Still 60-40.

Depressing.

A vote for bad health and bad taste in more ways than one.

GTAC Mining Hails "Magic" Of Its Plan

I read through this long, must-read description of the proposed GTAC open pit iron ore mine operation and reclamation plan, thought about writing something satirical about a Disney World Up North/Magic Mountain in the making, and was floored to see a company spokesman steal my thunder:

“People say how are you going to avoid impacts on these streams,” said [Bob] Seitz. “The magic of this is that we stay away from Ballou Creek, and we stay away from Tyler Forks.”

Massive Waste Rock Dumping Bad For Waters North And South

Residents in the Waukesha County community of Brookfield are not pleased to discover that WisDOT intends to let contractors dump large amounts of waste rock and other debris into a local quarry during the Zoo Interchange re-construction:

The company would dump as much as 1.8 million cubic yards of WisDOT-approved soil and clean fill from the Zoo Interchange project and other projects on top of shallow areas of the body of water on the property and surrounding land for up to seven years.
Angry residents are on video, here - -  and you can see their point. Who wants local water supplies, land, clean air and peace of mind abused that way?

And who trusts claims by the state government/dumping complex that the eventual outcomes won't be harmful?

And while we observe that Waukesha County residents demanded the Zoo Interchange expansion - - but hey, go dump the waste somewhere else, let's ask this, too:

Why didn't any state legislator from Brookfield or Waukesha County's all-GOP caucus speak up in favor of local controls, clean water and residential tranquility, and against even greater waste rock dumping planned across the Bad River watershed up north if and when open pit iron ore mining is permitted there?

Vast amounts of dumped and potentially-toxic waste rock - - over 35 years - - or five times longer than what might be sent Brookfield's way?

According to this newspaper report, quoting the state's fiscal bureau:
The bureau said that could result in about 29 million short tons — 2,000 pounds is a short ton — of waste rock annually and perhaps a billion tons of waste rock over 35 years. Annual waste would consist of about 18 million tons of tailings, the crushed ore waste left over from processing iron pellets, and 11 million tons of overburden, or rock overlaying or surrounding the ore body, according to the bureau.
Are some backyards created more equally than others?